An official website of the United States government.

This is not the current EPA website. To navigate to the current EPA website, please go to This website is historical material reflecting the EPA website as it existed on January 19, 2021. This website is no longer updated and links to external websites and some internal pages may not work. More information »

Working Paper: Muddying the Water? An Analysis of Non-Constant Baselines in Stated Preference Surveys

Paper Number: 2018-02

Document Date: 5/2018

Author(s): Kelly B. Maguire, Chris Moore, Dennis Guignet, Chris Dockins, Nathalie B. Simon

Subject Area(s): Water pollution, Economic Damages/Benefits, Valuation methods, Marine/Coastal Zone Resources

JEL Classification: Q51, Q53

Keywords: baseline, benefit-cost analysis, Chesapeake Bay, nonmarket valuation, stated preference survey

Abstract: Defining baseline conditions is a key component of regulatory benefit-cost analysis. Most stated preference studies assume that the current state of the world in the absence of additional policy action remains constant. In the time that passes while a regulation is evaluated, implemented, and produces the intended environmental impacts, however, this is unlikely to be the case. To address this largely unexplored area of nonmarket valuation, we administer a stated preference survey using a three-way split sample design. Respondents are either told future baseline conditions would remain constant, decline, or improve without additional policy interventions. While we find some evidence to support predictions of the standard theoretical model, we also find that behavioral and emotional reactions to the non-constant baseline scenarios muddy the waters, introducing some countervailing factors. These results have implications for the design and use of stated preference results in benefit-cost analysis.

This paper is part of the Environmental Economics Working Paper Series.

You may need a PDF reader to view some of the files on this page. See EPA’s About PDF page to learn more.